hi! those two pedals are totally different

the main difference is in the sound – SMMH is digital delay, DMM is an analog delay. there are of course “more gadgets” on the SMMH as you say, but i think the most important difference for you is the sound

I personally prefer the sound of analog delays. I owned the Stereo Memory Man w/Harazai briefly, but returned it because it unmistakeably sounded digital. A deal breaker for me. The disadvantage to analog delays is that there’s usually not an option for tap tempo, no looping capabilities, no presets, etc. They’re also more expensive.

You need to decide whether tone or convenience are more important to you. There is a very noticeable difference in the sound of analog and digital delays. Tone is more important to me.

There are analog delays with tap tempo, for example the Diamond Memory Lane. It costs $600.

I agree with the above. You may not be as averse to the sonic characteristics of digital delay though. Try out both analog and digital delays, and decide for yourself.